We optimized 27 photos of the kind service businesses publish (a plumber, an electrician, a dental clinic, a law firm, a roofer, a spa and 21 more) and recorded every byte. As AVIF at 2,048 px wide, the set went from 84.8 MB to 8.7 MB, 89.7% smaller, with every file scoring an SSIM of 0.99 or higher against the original at the same size. Two lessons stood out: one grainy photo made up a fifth of the final weight, and the AI-written captions needed a human edit before they could be published.
Key takeaways
- 27 photos: 84.8 MB of originals became 14.1 MB as JPG, 14.1 MB as WebP and 8.7 MB as AVIF.
- The median photo shrank by 93.9%; the median AVIF was 184 KB.
- One photo accounted for 21% of the AVIF total. Check your heaviest files individually.
- AI alt text was a good draft. AI captions sometimes slipped into marketing claims.
- 14 of the 27 originals fit within 3 MB; 4 were over 5 MB.
The photos and the method
These are the 27 service-business photos from our wider 54-photo sample run: trades (plumber, electrician, carpenter, roofer, construction crew, auto mechanic, cleaning service, kitchen renovation, roofing and solar, landscaping), healthcare (dental clinic, medical practice, physiotherapy, vet clinic, spa, yoga studio, optometrist), professional services (accountant, law firm, interior designer, architect) and local services (real estate listing, hair salon, barbershop, nail salon, tattoo studio, pet groomer). All are free-license Unsplash photos, not client files, and all originals were JPEGs.
Each went through Picture Optimizer's own pipeline at the High preset: resized to 2,048 px wide, metadata stripped, saved as JPG (quality 82), WebP (quality 82) and AVIF (quality 55), plus AVIF copies at 300, 768 and 1,024 px. For quality, we compared each AVIF with the original resized to the same size, using SSIM at 1,024 px. AI vision wrote alt text, a title, a caption and a file name for each photo. The run finished on 17 October 2026.
MB means 1,048,576 bytes, as our tool reports it. Percentages come from exact bytes.
The numbers
Version | Total | Smaller than originals by |
|---|---|---|
Originals | 84.8 MB (88,902,871 bytes) | n/a |
JPG, 2,048 px | 14.1 MB (14,832,380 bytes) | 83.3% |
WebP, 2,048 px | 14.1 MB (14,787,680 bytes) | 83.4% |
AVIF, 2,048 px | 8.7 MB (9,135,700 bytes) | 89.7% |
AVIF method: 1 − (9,135,700 ÷ 88,902,871) = 0.897.
Quality: the lowest SSIM was 0.9908 (an interior designer's photo) and the median 0.9957.
For responsive use, the AVIF copies of all 27 photos totaled 313 KB at 300 px, 1.3 MB at 768 px and 2.1 MB at 1,024 px. A phone loading a 768 px version of every photo would download about 14% of the 8.7 MB full-size set.
Three examples
Photo | Original | AVIF | Smaller by | SSIM |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Plumber under a kitchen sink | 2.8 MB | 55 KB | 98.1% | 0.9966 |
Dental treatment room | 1.9 MB | 118 KB | 93.9% | 0.9938 |
Law firm document signing | 5.6 MB | 245 KB | 95.7% | 0.9927 |
Lesson 1: one photo can outweigh twenty
The yoga studio photo, a backlit sunset silhouette with film-style grain, was only 2,202 px wide to begin with. It shrank from 2.46 MB to 1.86 MB, 24.1%, and on its own made up 21% of the 8.7 MB AVIF total. Without it, the other 26 photos went from 82.3 MB to 6.8 MB, a 91.7% reduction.
The practical point for a business site: after a batch, sort by output size and look at the top few. A heavy outlier can be cropped tighter, displayed smaller, or replaced with a cleaner shot. Lowering the quality for the whole batch to fix one photo would cost the others for nothing.
Lesson 2: file size limits matter more than you'd think
By original file size, 14 of the 27 photos were 3 MB or smaller, 9 were between 3 and 5 MB, and 4 were over 5 MB (the largest, an auto mechanic photo, was 7.4 MB at 11,648 × 8,736 px). Photos from good cameras often exceed small upload limits. When a tool or plan has a per-file cap, check how it handles bigger files: refusing them, or resizing them first. Our Free plan resizes photos over 3 MB to fit; Starter keeps originals up to 5 MB and Pro up to 30 MB.
Lesson 3: AI alt text was a good draft
All 27 alt texts were specific and short, from 68 to 116 characters, and none began with "image of." For example:
- Plumber: "Plumber repairing white PVC sink drainage pipes under a kitchen sink with blue lighting"
- Roofer: "Roofer in a high-visibility yellow shirt installing asphalt shingles on a residential roof under a clear sky"
- Auto mechanic: "Close-up of a mechanic's hands using a wrench to repair a dark car engine component"
What the AI can't know is context. On a plumber's own site, "blue lighting" matters less than the service or the town. W3C guidance is to convey the image's meaning on that page, which is a human decision. Two of the 54 alt texts in the wider run mentioned a person's ethnicity, which we chose not to show as examples; that's also a judgment to make per photo.
Lesson 4: AI captions needed the most editing
Captions are visible on the page, so they read like claims. Eleven of the 27 used the word "professional". Two went further:
- Dental clinic: "Our state-of-the-art dental clinic features advanced technology in a clean, calming environment designed for patient comfort."
- Spa: "Experience ultimate tranquility with our professional hot stone therapy designed to relieve tension and promote deep relaxation."
Those are marketing claims written about a stock photo. A business should only publish a caption it can stand behind: replace generic praise with a fact ("Treatment room 2 at our Main Street clinic, refitted in 2025"), or drop the caption.
What we'd do on a real service-business site
- Resize and convert every photo; AVIF where the platform accepts it, JPG otherwise.
- Sort the output by size and fix the heaviest few by hand.
- Use AI alt text as a draft and add the context only you know.
- Rewrite or remove captions that make claims.
- Keep the responsive sizes; phones are where the savings show.
Try it on your own photos
Our local businesses page shows how this works for a small business site. The Free plan compresses your first 15 photos, once, as AVIF or JPG, with no AI; Starter ($19 a month) adds AI alt text, titles, captions and file names that you review before export, plus WebP output and responsive sizes. Details on the alt text generator and pricing pages.
Keep reading
Sources
Questions
Short answers to what people ask about this.