ShortPixel vs Imagify vs Smush: which WordPress optimizer fits your site?

Three popular WordPress image plugins compared on free limits, pricing, WebP and AVIF, backups and alt text, from their official pages in October 2026.

By
Picture Optimizer team
Published
Type
Comparison

All three are established WordPress image plugins, and all three will make a typical media library lighter. The differences are in how you pay and what's included: ShortPixel sells credits and lists AI alt text, Imagify sells monthly data allowances with flat plans, and Smush has a free version on WordPress.org, with WebP and AVIF listed as Pro. We checked every fact below on each plugin's WordPress.org page and official site on 22 October 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Lowest-effort free option: Smush, for libraries that don't need WebP or AVIF from the free version.
  • Pay for what you process: ShortPixel, with monthly credits or one-time packs that don't expire.
  • Predictable flat plans: Imagify, sold by megabytes per month, with an unlimited tier.
  • Alt text in the same plugin: ShortPixel is the only one of the three that lists AI alt text.

Side by side

ShortPixel

Imagify

Smush

Active installs (WordPress.org)

300,000+

1+ million

1+ million

Free tier

100 credits a month

20 MB a month

Free version on WordPress.org

Paid model

Unlimited monthly from $9.99; one-time packs from $19.99

Growth $5.99/month (500 MB); Infinite $11.99/month

Pro from $50/year for 1 site

Compression modes

Lossy, glossy, lossless

Smart compression by default; optional lossless

Lossless and lossy in free; "Ultra" in Pro

WebP and AVIF

Yes

Yes

Listed as Pro

Backups and restore

Yes, one-click restore

Yes, originals kept in a separate folder

Not verified

AI alt text

Listed (alt text, captions, descriptions)

Not listed

Not listed

Largest image

Not verified

2 MB per image on the free plan

Not listed on the official pages

"Not listed" and "not verified" mean we didn't find it on the official pages we checked.

ShortPixel

ShortPixel's plugin offers three modes: lossless for pixel-perfect output, glossy as a balance, and lossy for the smallest files. It converts to WebP and AVIF and backs up originals locally for one-click restore. It's also the only plugin of the three whose WordPress.org page lists AI-generated alt text, captions and image descriptions.

Pricing is credit-based. The plugin page lists 100 free credits a month, unlimited monthly credits from $9.99, and one-time credit packages from $19.99 that never expire. ShortPixel's pricing page loads its plan table dynamically, so confirm the billing period there.

Good fit: sites that add images in bursts, or that want compression and missing alt text handled by one plugin.

Imagify

Imagify compresses with a "smart" default and an optional lossless mode, converts to WebP and AVIF from the WordPress dashboard, and stores originals in a separate folder so you can restore them.

The free plan covers 20 MB a month, with a 2 MB limit per image. Imagify's pricing page lists Growth at $5.99 a month (or $4.99 billed yearly) for 500 MB a month, with extra data at $5 per GB, and Infinite at $11.99 a month (or $9.99 billed yearly) with no limit.

Good fit: owners who want a simple setting and a predictable monthly bill, especially on the unlimited plan.

Smush

Smush, from WPMU DEV, has a free version on WordPress.org with lossless and lossy compression, bulk and single-image compression and lazy loading.

According to WPMU DEV, Smush Pro adds higher compression, CDN delivery and WebP support; the WordPress.org feature list marks automatic WebP and AVIF serving as Pro. (The same page's FAQ says Smush can convert to WebP and AVIF without mentioning Pro, so check the current plugin if you rely on the free version for this.) Pro is listed at $50 a year for 1 site, $75 for 3 sites and $100 for 10 sites.

Good fit: smaller sites with moderate image sizes that want free compression and lazy loading, and agencies managing several sites on one Pro plan.

How to choose by type of site

  • A small brochure site with a few dozen images a year: any of the three free tiers will cover it. Smush's free version lists no monthly allowance on its WordPress.org page; Imagify's 20 MB a month and ShortPixel's 100 credits are enough for light use.
  • A blog that publishes images every week: estimate your monthly volume. A flat plan (Imagify Infinite) makes billing predictable; ShortPixel's one-time packs suit irregular publishing.
  • A store or a large old library: look at the bulk tools, backups and per-image size limits first. Imagify's free plan caps images at 2 MB, so large product photos may need a paid tier; check each plugin's current limits before you commit.
  • A site with thousands of images missing alt text: compression alone won't fix that. ShortPixel lists AI alt text; otherwise plan a separate alt text pass.

Before you install any of them

  1. Back up the site (files and database) before the first bulk run.
  2. Check server support for AVIF under Tools > Site Health > Info > Media Handling if you plan to serve it through WordPress itself.
  3. Run 10 to 20 images first and check that posts still display them in every size.
  4. Avoid running two optimizers on the same images. Compressing an already compressed file wastes credits and can add artifacts.

A fourth option: Picture Optimizer's plugin

We make a WordPress plugin too, so weigh this paragraph accordingly. Picture Optimizer's WordPress plugin runs on the Pro plan ($49 a month, 1,000 credits, 7-day trial). It processes images already in your library on our servers, converts to WebP or AVIF, writes alt text, a title, a caption and a file name, replaces the original, regenerates thumbnails, updates every link with redirects, and can revert any image. It costs more per image than the plugins above; it makes sense when you want the written metadata done at the same time. Plans and credit costs are on our pricing page.

Keep reading

Sources

Questions

Short answers to what people ask about this.

It depends on volume and features. ShortPixel's free tier is 100 credits a month and its plugin lists AI alt text; Imagify's free tier is 20 MB a month with flat monthly plans. Both convert to WebP and AVIF and keep originals for restore.

How-to · WordPress images

How to serve WebP and AVIF in WordPress

Four ways to get WebP and AVIF onto a WordPress site, from uploading them directly to converting an existing library, and how to check your server first.